Who Should Shape Your Brand? Understanding the Roles of Leadership in Branding Decisions‍

Who Should Shape Your Brand? Understanding the Roles of Leadership in Branding Decisions

Aaron C. Leaman

 / 

May 1, 2024

Aaron C. Leaman

Building a brand is one of the most strategic investments an organisation can make. But branding is rarely a solo effort. From the CEO to the CFO, and from the CMO to the CTO, every leader has a perspective—and often an opinion—on how the brand should look, feel, and operate.

While collaboration is essential, misalignment among leadership can create chaos, dilute the brand’s direction, and even derail its success. So, how do you balance these perspectives while ensuring your brand remains cohesive and impactful?

Let’s break down the roles of key leaders in branding and explore how their input can drive—or hinder—your success.

The Role of Leadership in Branding

Branding requires contributions from multiple stakeholders, but not all voices carry equal weight. Here’s how each role fits into the branding process, from strategy to execution:

CEO’s Perspective: The Visionary Leader

Strengths:

  • Sets the organisation’s vision, mission, and long-term strategy.
  • Balances cultural, operational, and financial priorities to ensure the brand aligns with overarching goals.
  • Acts as the ultimate decision-maker, providing strategic direction for the brand’s development.

Limitations:

  • May micromanage, causing the brand to reflect personal preferences rather than strategic alignment.
  • Can overlook executional realities in favour of big-picture thinking, risking misalignment with practical needs.

Role in Decision-Making:

The CEO is the steward of the brand, responsible for ensuring it reflects the company’s purpose and values. Their role is to align stakeholders, protect the brand’s integrity, and guide it as a long-term investment.

Brand Builder’s Perspective: The Creative Architect

Strengths:

  • Brings expertise in storytelling, design, and crafting a compelling brand identity.
  • Creates emotional resonance and ensures the brand aligns with audience expectations.
  • Offers an objective, outsider perspective free from internal politics.

Limitations:

  • May focus heavily on creativity without fully understanding internal constraints or business objectives.
  • Risks undervaluing operational considerations in favour of bold ideas.

Role in Decision-Making:

The brand builder—whether an external agency or an internal creative lead—is essential for translating the organisation’s vision into a powerful, cohesive brand. Their voice should carry significant weight, as they are uniquely equipped to execute the creative and strategic elements of branding.

CMO’s Perspective: The Market Strategist

Strengths:

  • Leads market research and customer insights to ensure the brand resonates with the target audience.
  • Develops campaigns and strategies that bring the brand to life across marketing channels.
  • Understands competitive positioning and how to differentiate the brand in the market.

Limitations:

  • Can focus too narrowly on marketing metrics, potentially neglecting broader cultural or operational considerations.
  • May prioritise trends over long-term strategy, risking a lack of brand longevity.

Role in Decision-Making:

The CMO bridges strategy and execution, ensuring branding decisions are audience-focused and market-driven. Their expertise is critical for aligning the brand with customer expectations and competitive realities.

Head of Communications’ Perspective: The Consistency Champion

Strengths:

  • Ensures consistency in messaging across internal and external audiences.
  • Embeds the brand’s values into organisational culture and communications.
  • Manages how the brand is perceived by employees, partners, and the public.

Limitations:

  • May overemphasise internal alignment, risking delays in responding to market dynamics.
  • Could struggle to balance the needs of internal and external stakeholders effectively.

Role in Decision-Making:

The Head of Communications ensures the brand resonates across all touchpoints. Their input ensures alignment between internal culture and external positioning, making the brand authentic and relatable.

CCO’s Perspective: The Revenue Driver

Strengths:

  • Aligns the brand with revenue-generating activities like sales, partnerships, and business development.
  • Focuses on customer engagement, retention strategies, and commercial growth opportunities.
  • Provides insights into how the brand supports profitability and market share.

Limitations:

  • May prioritise short-term commercial goals over long-term brand equity.
  • Risks framing the brand too narrowly around sales or revenue objectives, missing its broader impact.

Role in Decision-Making:

The CCO ensures the brand aligns with commercial objectives, advocating for decisions that enhance customer loyalty, partnerships, and overall market relevance.

CTO’s Perspective: The Technological Strategist

Strengths:

  • Aligns the brand with technological innovation and the organisation’s digital capabilities.
  • Provides insights into how technology can enhance the brand experience (e.g., user interfaces, platforms, or product design).
  • Ensures the brand’s messaging reflects the organisation’s technological strengths.

Limitations:

  • May overemphasise technical aspects, potentially overshadowing the brand’s emotional or cultural elements.
  • Could struggle to translate technological advantages into relatable messaging for non-technical audiences.

Role in Decision-Making:

The CTO’s role is often advisory, ensuring the brand reflects technological credibility and innovation. Their perspective is particularly valuable in tech-driven organisations where digital experiences are central to the brand.

CFO’s Perspective: The Financial Gatekeeper

Strengths:

  • Ensures branding investments align with budgetary constraints and ROI expectations.
  • Evaluates the long-term financial implications of branding decisions, such as rebranding costs or campaign effectiveness.

Limitations:

  • Often focuses on measurable outcomes, potentially undervaluing intangible brand benefits like emotional connection, culture-building, or market positioning.
  • May prioritise cost-cutting over strategic investments, risking the brand’s long-term impact.

Role in Decision-Making:

The CFO’s input is vital for ensuring financial feasibility but should remain supportive of creative and strategic decisions. Their role is to complement the brand’s vision with financial sustainability.

Why Balancing These Perspectives Matters

While each leader brings valuable insights, unbalanced decision-making can undermine the brand. For example:

  • When the CFO dominates, branding becomes purely financial, losing its creative and emotional impact.
  • When the CEO micromanages, the brand risks reflecting personal preferences rather than strategic alignment.
  • When internal teams lack freedom, creativity is stifled, and the brand becomes generic.

A successful brand requires clear leadership, defined roles, and respect for expertise. The CEO must ensure collaboration while empowering the right people to lead the creative and strategic process.

Conclusion: A Brand is a Collective Effort

Building a brand is not a one-person job, nor is it the responsibility of just one department. It requires input from across the organisation—but with defined roles and responsibilities. CEOs, CMOs, and brand builders must lead the charge, while financial and technological perspectives serve as vital support.

By balancing these perspectives, organisations can create brands that inspire employees, engage customers, and resonate with investors—delivering value far beyond the bottom line.

Call to Action:

Have you experienced conflicting leadership priorities in branding decisions? How do you balance creativity, strategy, and financial oversight? Share your thoughts, and let’s explore how organisations can collaborate to build impactful brands.

Facebook sharing IconTwitter sharing IconPinterest sharing IconWhatsApp sharing IconLinkedin sharing Icon

Join our Newsletter.

Want valuable insights from some of the world’s most successful planet-driven founders? Join our Origin Story newsletter. Each one of our Origin Story interviews dives deep into the mind of a planet-driven founder, reveals insights about their company’s DNA, and investigates how they’ve built a successful business.

BY ENTERING YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS, YOU AGREE TO BE ADDED YOU TO OUR MAILING LIST.

Let’s Tell Your Story.

Book call

Your Vision, Our Mission.

Book call

The Cost of Cutting Corners: Why Brand Builders Are Essential Beyond Launch‍

Who Should Shape Your Brand? Understanding the Roles of Leadership in Branding Decisions‍

The Hidden Cost of Delayed Branding in Climate

Investor Spotlight: Abe Murray, Alley Corp

Driving Culture and Impact with Inside-Out Storytelling

Investor Spotlight: Helmer Schukken, Rubio Impact Ventures

Mastering the Art of the Teaser Deck

Why We Work Exclusively with Climate and Impact-Focused Companies

Investor Spotlight: Jan Lozek, Future Energy Ventures

Investor Spotlight: Carlota Ochoa Neven Du Mont, Extantia Capital

Building a Strong Data Room for Investors & Shareholders

Mastering Your Monthly Startup Investor Updates: A Ready-to-Use Template

Why Many Climate and Impact Startups Fail (And What You Can Do About It)

Branding is the Strategic Foundation (and Why Marketing Should Come After)‍

How Design by Committee Kills Creativity: Insights for Companies Undergoing Rebranding

How to Drive Growth and Impact Through Storytelling

A Vision Story - Why You Need It and How You Craft It

The Core of Connection: Telling Your Purpose Story

‍Mastering Customer Insights: The Quick-Path Method to Developing Customer Personas

Investor Spotlight: Tim Hoerr, Serra Ventures

Investor Spotlight: Tom Rand, ArcTern Ventures

Investor Spotlight Interview W/ Nick Cooney, Lever VC

Investor Spotlight Interview W/ Danny Brown, MaC Venture Capital

Investor Spotlight Interview W/ Josep Oriol, Okavango Capital

Investor Spotlight Interview W/ Michael Dean, AgFunder

Investor Spotlight Interview W/ Jonny Everett, Marble

The Evolution and Impact of Science Communication

Investor Spotlight Interview W/ Myke Näf, Übermorgen Ventures

Investor Spotlight Series Interview W/ Anthony Chow, Agronomics

Breaking the Mold: Impossible Foods' Bold Approach to Plant-Based Marketing

Investor Spotlight Series w/ Nick Lyth, Green Angel Ventures

Origin Story Interview W/ Manuel Seiffe, MPower

Origin Story Interview W/ Aarav Chavda, INVERSA Leathers

Origin Story Interview W/ Florian Tiller, Ucaneo

Origin Story Interview W/ Richard Hardiman, RanMarine

Origin Story Interview W/ Johnny Drain, Win-Win

A Lesson from Patagonia on Developing Brand Values

Origin Story Interview W/ David Henstrom, Unibio

Origin Story Interview W/ Steffen Gerlach, Eeden

Origin Story Interview W/ Kevin Webb, Superorganism

An Origin Story - Why You Need It And How To Craft It

Origin Story Interview W/ Dustin Bowers, PLAEX

Origin Story Interview W/ John Vermilye, Fair Carbon

Origin Story Interview W/ Thibaut Monfort-Micheo, FlexSea

Origin Story Interview W/ Andrew Behar, As You Sow

Origin Story Interview W/ Ruben Smit, Sunrise

Origin Story Series W/ Deepak Rajmohan, GreenPod Labs

Origin Story Interview W/ Christopher McClure, Loki Foods

Narratives of Change: Crafting Identity through Founder and Organisational Storytelling

Origin Story Interview W/ Emmanuel Briquet, Searen

How to Use an Origin and Vision Story to Attract Investors

The Power of Storytelling: How Climate Activists Drive Meaningful Change

Transforming IPCC Narratives for Global Climate Awareness

Origin Story Interview W/ Hannes Junginger, Carbonfuture

Origin Story Interview W/ David Monnier, Fonto de Vivo

Origin Story Interview W/ Tim Steppich, ClimateU

Origin Story Interview W/ Mark Driscoll, Tasting the Future

Origin Story Interview W/ Kalle Nilvér, GoClimate

Origin Story Interview W/ Marina Schmidt, Red to Green

Origin Story Interview W/ Christoph Pitter, ProteinDistillery

Origin Story Interview W/ Antonella De Lazzari, Naturannova

Origin Story Interview W/ Dijana Galijasevic, Impact Hero

Origin Story Interview W/ Anastasia Kiku, Reusables

Origin Story Interview W/ Nathan Bonnisseau, Plan A

Origin Story Interview W/ Ryan Kushner, Third Derivative

Origin Story Interview W/ Philipp Arbter, Colipi

Origin Story Interview W/ Thibault Sorret, ERS

Origin Story Interview W/ Csaba Hetényi, Plantcraft

Origin Story Interview W/ Rhea Singhal, Ecoware

Origin Story Interview W/ Joel Tasche, CleanHub

Origin Story Interview W/ Jennifer Cote, Opalia

Origin Story Interview W/ Allen Himes, Indigo Energy

Origin Story Interview W/ Emily Taylor, SAGES

Origin Story Interview W/ Aaron Schaller, MeliBio

Origin Story Interview W/ Clover Hogan, Force of Nature

Origin Story Interview W/ Bernard de Wit, Regreener

Origin Story Interview W/ Wolfgang Baum, Fairventures Worldwide gGmbH

Origin Story Interview W/ Anne Therese Gennari, The Climate Optimist

Origin Story Interview W/ Frederique De Clercq, Fred's Mayo

Origin Story Interview W/ Dimitry Gershenson, Enduring Planet

Origin Story Interview W/ David Cutler, Fortuna Cools

Origin Story Interview w/ Auriane Borremans, The Butcher's Daughter & Eatention

Origin Story Interview w/ Will Wiseman, Climatize

Origin Story Interview w/ Todd Khozein, SecondMuse

Origin Story Interview w/ Ryan Hagen, Crowdsourcing Sustainability

Origin Story Interview w/ Noor, Project CECE

Origin Story Interview w/ Shobhita Soor, Legendary Foods

Origin Story Interview W/ Yvonne Jamal, JARO Institute for Sustainability and Digitalization

Origin Story Interview w/ Paul Shapiro, The Better Meat Co.

Origin Story Interview W/ Topher White, Rainforest Connection & Squibbon

Origin Story Interview W/ Felipe Krelling, NewBio

Origin Story Interview W/ Samuel Wines, Co-Labs Australia

Origin Story Interview W/ Mirjam Walser, The Vegan Business School

Origin Story Interview W/ Walid Al Saqqaf, Rebalance Earth

Origin Story Interview W/ Ana Rosa de Lima, Meli Bees

Origin Story Interview W/ Maya Ashkenazi, Maolac

Origin Story Interview W/ Vanessa Westphal, Choosy

Origin Story Interview W/ Leah Bessa, De Novo Dairy

Origin Story Interview W/ Jasmin Shaikh, Axia Foods

Origin Story Interview W/ Roee Nir, Forsea